How We Evaluated Jump Starters

2024-11-26 09:48:52 hgg27704932 56

We wheeled the ice-cold Eclipse into the Car and Driver garage and got to work. The car's battery was so shot that, during testing, we watched its juice discharge between each test with our voltmeter. This was very handy—we didn't have to discharge the battery manually after each jump. Once the battery discharged fully, we hooked up each unit and tried them out.

Because the car battery was drained each time we hooked a jumper to it, some of the portable jump starters would read the connection as a "reverse polarity" error (we hooked it up correctly, we promise). This was fascinating—but also unveiled a flaw with some of the new-style jump starters. Those without a manual override button would not recognize the connection, so they simply wouldn't work. We understand the need for this fail-safe, but the inability to override the error manually and get a jolt from the unit eliminated one of the jump starters we planned to test and required another to be stabilized with a new battery in order to go back and jump-start the Eclipse—not much help if you're stranded on the side of the road.

Along with checking if each jump starter successfully started the car, we also tested the following parameters:

  • Total energy it took to recharge the units from complete depletion (using a Kill-A-Watt) to sense-check the energy capacity claims

  • Weight

  • Ease of Use

  • Lead length (measured from base of lead to end of clamp)

  • Clamp quality

  • Portability (for portable jump starters)

  • Stability under the hood (for power stations)

  • Additional features

Comparing our notes on these parameters helped us choose which portable jump starters were the best and which didn't make the cut. Here are our top picks for the best portable jump starters.